Compare and Contrast Using Tables and Charts

Venn Diagram Alternative: Using Tables to Compare and Contrast. Teach 3rd grade and 4th grade students how to compare and contrast in a variety of ways.

Teachers (myself included) tend to default to a Venn Diagram when teaching comparing and contrasting. While this can be a useful tool for helping students understand how to identify similarities and differences, we often forget that there are a variety of other ways to teach students how to compare and contrast. Tables are one of my favorite.

Venn Diagram Alternative: Using Tables to Compare and Contrast.  Teach 3rd grade and 4th grade students how to compare and contrast in a variety of ways.

Teaching students how to use and create tables in order to compare and contrast can be beneficial to students for a variety of reasons, including:

• Tables are important text features in nonfiction that students should be able to read and interpret
• Tables help to organize information in an organized, easy-to-understand way
• Creating and interpreting tables usually requires more higher level thinking than creating and interpreting a Venn Diagram.
• Tables allow you to more easily compare and contrast more than 2 things.

Ways to Compare and Contrast Using Tables

1. Have students compare themselves with a peer. This is a fun introduction activity to comparing and contrasting, as well as a good team builder. Have partners or small groups fill in a chart together that allows them to see similarities and differences between themselves. Students can compare and contrast things like favorite foods, family, where they were born, hobbies, favorite music, etc.  Download a free chart that students can use to compare and contrast themselves with a partner here:  Compare and Contrast with a Partner: Chart

2. Have students compare themselves with a character from a book. Have students complete a table that allows them to see similarities and differences between themselves and another character.

3. Have students compare 2 or more texts. As you read different fiction texts with your students, have them fill in a table that helps them compare and contrast things like the settings, characters, plot, theme, etc. Or, if you are reading non-fiction, you can have students compare and contrast text features used, the point of view of the author, main idea, etc.

4. Have students compare 2 or more characters within a single text. Have students create a table that compares things like physical appearance of the characters, important character traits, what the characters believe about a certain topic, the characters’ family, etc.

5. Create a table that allows students to compare and contrast science and social studies skills. This is a great way to help students remember and organize important information. This works perfectly for many science and social studies skills – landforms, biomes, famous people, holidays, animals, planets, etc.

6. Create tables to help scaffold student note taking. This works especially well when presenting Powerpoints or other presentations. Instead of just having students listen, provide them with a table to fill in as you discuss the topic. The table can be as simple or as complex as you like. If you are discussing famous inventors, for example, students could fill in a two-columned table that has them write the name of the inventor and the important invention.

Differentiation

Tables provide teachers with an easy way to differentiate based on the needs of students, with a little advance planning. Students can be provided tables with different amounts filled in for them, ranging from a table with only a few blank spaces to fill in for students that need extra scaffolding, to completely blank tables for students that are ready to come up with their own categories for comparison (talk about higher level thinking!)

However you decide to use tables in to compare and contrast in your classroom, your students will benefit from learning to read and interpret tables.

Never Stress Over Sub Plans Again!

When you subscribe to my newsletter below, I’ll send you my Reusable Sub Plans for FREE. You’ll also get updates on new blog posts and freebies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *